Why Local Personal Trainers on Long Island Are Leaving Big Gyms for Better Careers
Being a personal trainer is often sold as a dream career. The idea of helping people get stronger, healthier, and more confident every day is deeply rewarding. You get to see transformations, inspire others, and make a real impact on people’s lives. But if you’ve worked as a trainer for any length of time, you know the reality can be very different—especially if you’ve spent time at a big-box gym. Long hours, split shifts, constantly chasing clients, and the stress of managing your own business can make personal training feel like a grind rather than a fulfilling career.
After more than a decade in the industry, I’ve experienced the full spectrum of the personal training lifestyle. From early mornings to late evenings, juggling clients, navigating cancellations, and dealing with other trainers trying to “poach” your clients, it’s easy to feel exhausted and undervalued. That’s why I created AB Fitness—to give personal trainers the career, lifestyle, and support they deserve.
This article will explore what it’s really like to be a personal trainer, share day-in-the-life anecdotes, discuss the personal training lifestyle, and explain why joining AB Fitness in East Meadow, Massapequa, or Oyster Bay is a game-changer for local trainers looking for stability, growth, and fulfillment.
The Reality of Being a Personal Trainer at a Big-Box Gym
When I first started, I was promised the world. I was told I’d be helping clients, building relationships, and having the freedom to grow as a trainer. The reality? Not even close. I quickly learned that the role was mostly sales, not training. My days were spent walking the floor, trying to convince members to buy training packages, while actual client sessions were sparse.
For months, I made barely more than minimum wage. I’d start my day in a split shift, showing up early in the morning and working until late morning, then returning in the afternoon and staying until 8 p.m., five days a week, plus weekends. I was exhausted, and I wasn’t even training full-time; I was chasing clients just to make ends meet.
And when a client canceled? That slot was gone—and so was the income. I remember walking into the gym with a full schedule, only to see half my clients cancel by 10 a.m. That’s not uncommon in the big-box gym world. A client who was supposed to be there at 7:30 a.m. would cancel without notice, and I’d be left staring at empty appointment slots until the next client arrived at 5 p.m. Even though I earned money during sessions, when I averaged it out over the hours I put in, it barely added up to more than minimum wage.
Other trainers would often try to steal clients. Loyalty was hard to come by in an environment that prioritized sales over relationships. Any cancellation meant lost income, and I lived in constant fear: what if something happened to me? My income was entirely dependent on me showing up. I hated getting sick because it meant losing pay. Every personal day, every emergency, every illness could put my finances in jeopardy. That fear was exhausting, and it made me hate being human, because as a personal trainer in that system, your paycheck depended entirely on whether you were standing on the floor.
Day in the Life: A Trainer’s Grind at a Big Gym
A typical day at a big-box gym felt like a marathon with no finish line. I’d arrive before sunrise for my first shift, fully expecting to have a packed schedule. But by 9:30 a.m., several clients would cancel. I’d spend time waiting, reaching out, trying to fill the gaps, all while juggling the needs of the clients who did show up.
In the afternoon, I’d return for the second shift, exhausted from the morning, only to repeat the same cycle. By evening, I might only have two clients left, and those sessions were the only money I’d make for hours of effort. Even during training sessions, while I was actively earning, the rest of my time was spent chasing leads, making sales pitches, and dealing with administrative headaches.
It wasn’t just the hours that wore me down—it was the constant unpredictability. You could have a day where everything lined up perfectly, then a single cancellation could wipe out a significant portion of your income. The stress and instability made it hard to focus on training, building relationships, or improving your skills. It became clear that if I wanted a career as a personal trainer, I needed a better model—one that allowed me to focus on what I loved while providing stability, growth, and support.
Why AB Fitness Was Created: A Better Life for Trainers
That realization led to the creation of AB Fitness. I wanted to build a gym where trainers could actually train instead of constantly selling or hustling for clients. AB Fitness was designed with the trainer’s lifestyle in mind, focusing on stability, professional growth, and the tools to succeed.
At AB Fitness, we make schedules concrete, meaning trainers know exactly when they’ll work and what sessions they have. You get paid regardless of cancellations, so income isn’t tied to the whims of a client’s schedule. This takes the stress off trainers and allows them to focus on training, rather than constantly worrying about filling gaps in the day.
Our model is team-based, which means trainers work together to give clients the best possible experience. We emphasize collaboration over competition, creating an environment where trainers support one another instead of fighting for clients. This builds a sense of community among our team while ensuring clients receive consistent, high-quality coaching.
Ongoing Training and Professional Growth
AB Fitness doesn’t just give you a schedule and clients—we invest in your professional development. Our trainers go through ongoing training programs to ensure they’re constantly improving their coaching skills, learning new techniques, and staying up-to-date with the latest in fitness and wellness. You’ll learn how to maximize results for clients, manage small groups, and scale your impact.
Our Results App tracks client progress, weights, and workouts, so trainers have a data-driven approach to coaching. You can see exactly how clients are progressing and adjust programs accordingly. This allows you to help more clients effectively and efficiently, creating better results and higher client satisfaction.
Trainers Get to Focus on Training, Not Sales
At AB Fitness, if you’re a trainer, you actually get to train. No selling memberships, no cold calls, no hustling for clients. You focus on what you love: helping people improve their strength, mobility, confidence, and overall health. By removing the business and sales burden, trainers can create a sustainable career, improve client outcomes, and enjoy a better work-life balance.
We also offer paid vacation and holidays, because trainers deserve a life outside the gym. Stability, growth, and work-life balance are core to our philosophy.
Impact and Career Growth: The AB Fitness Ladder
At AB Fitness, there’s a clear ladder of success for trainers. Every career starts as a Junior Trainer, where you focus on developing your skills, working with clients, and mastering the fundamentals. As you gain experience, you can become a Head Trainer, mentoring junior trainers, taking on leadership responsibilities, and refining your coaching style. From there, the next step is Facility Leader, essentially functioning as a mini-owner, overseeing operations, staff, and client experience at one location. The top rung is Regional Manager, where you oversee multiple locations, guide teams of Facility Leaders, and help drive the strategic growth of AB Fitness in the region. This career ladder gives trainers direction, purpose, and real opportunities for growth, something that is rarely available in traditional gyms.
What Our Trainers Say: Real Experiences at AB Fitness
We could talk all day about schedules, shared clients, and career growth, but the real proof is in the voices of the trainers who work at AB Fitness. These are anonymous testimonials from our East Meadow, Massapequa, and Oyster Bay locations:
Trainer Mike – Early-Career Trainer
“Before AB Fitness, I was constantly stressed trying to find clients. Now I can focus on being a trainer instead of a salesperson. The schedule is structured, my clients are consistent, and I get to work alongside other trainers who genuinely support each other.”
Trainer John – Experienced Trainer
“The onboarding program was incredible—practical, hands-on, and designed to help me fine-tune my skills. I finally have the freedom to focus on training, not chasing leads or selling packages. It’s a game-changer.”
Trainer Angelo – Trainer Focusing on Small Group Training
“Small group sessions allow me to train more clients efficiently while still offering individualized attention. The Results App lets me track progress, and clients are motivated because they can see results every week.”
Trainer Brianna – Trainer Who Values Work-Life Balance
“Paid vacations and holidays are life-changing. I finally have a personal life outside the gym, and I don’t have to worry about lost income from cancellations. AB Fitness respects my time and my career.”
These testimonials highlight the stability, professional growth, and lifestyle improvements AB Fitness offers, and why it’s the best place for personal trainers.
Join AB Fitness and Transform Your Career
If you’ve experienced the grind of big-box gyms, the stress of unstable schedules, and the frustration of low pay, it’s time to consider a different path. At AB Fitness, trainers have the support, stability, and tools to focus on training clients, grow their careers, and enjoy the lifestyle they deserve.
Click here to apply and join the AB Fitness team
Locations:
-
East Meadow: 514a East Meadow Ave, East Meadow, NY 11554
-
Massapequa: 4150c Merrick Road, Massapequa, NY 11758
-
Oyster Bay: 5 Shore Ave, Oyster Bay, NY 11771